Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

The Body Shop’s demise: What went wrong?

This contributio delves into the unexpected demise of The Body Shop, a once-iconic emblem of ethical consumption and environmental stewardship, which succumbed to corporate insolvency. Tracing the brand's decline, the article identifies a blend of strategic missteps and external challenges, notably the dilution of its ethical identity amidst ownership changes and the seismic shifts in consumer behaviour prompted by the Covid-19 pandemic. These factors alienated loyal customers and impeded competition in a digital marketplace increasingly crowded with brands flaunting ethical credentials. The narrative further explores missed opportunities for rejuvenation, such as leveraging its B Corp certification and enhancing its digital presence, which could have reinvigorated consumer engagement and staved off its downfall.

Read More
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Ponzi, pyramids, and pensions: The BHI heist

The article discusses the BHI Trust scandal, highlighting its nature as a Ponzi scheme and its impact on investors. It draws parallels to historical financial frauds, emphasising the dangers of unregulated investment opportunities. The narrative details the investigation into BHI Trust's operations, the alleged fraudulent activities of trustee Craig Warriner, and the legal efforts to recover investor funds. It underscores the importance of regulatory compliance and investor education to prevent such schemes. The article serves as a cautionary tale about the risks associated with high-return investment promises and the potential for financial deceit.

Read More
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

The mirage of moral high ground: SA’s foreign policy distraction

The recent spectacle of South Africa posturing at the ICJ, levelling accusations of genocide against Israel, has ignited a fiery discourse on the dissonance between its foreign policy endeavours and the grim realities of its socioeconomic theatre. This foray into international jurisprudence, with its pointed finger at Israel, emerges as a glaring misallocation of focus, a distraction dance from the more pressing ballet of domestic crises: economic inertia, rampant joblessness, and an energy sector teetering on the brink of collapse.

These are not abstract issues but real plights gnawing at the lives of millions of South Africans, demanding not just attention but action, a return to the governance ethos once championed by the likes of Nelson Mandela – governance of the people, by the people, for the people, where reconciliation and justice are not merely rhetorical flourishes but lived realities.

Yet, here stands South Africa, embroiled in a quagmire of its own making, its credibility and moral authority haemorrhaging on the altar of international diplomacy, a testament to hypocrisy so profound it echoes the story of “The Emperor Has No Clothes”.

The urgent call for a realignment of priorities transcends mere criticism, emerging as a fervent appeal for rationality – a nudge towards the values that have now faded into obscurity. As the nation continues to project itself onto the global stage, wrestling with the paradox of advocating for international human rights while its own house is in disarray, the international community’s gaze will be fixed on its actions and the coherence and integrity of its stance.

The balancing act between global advocacy and domestic exigency is not just a diplomatic tightrope but a measure of South Africa’s fidelity to its democratic promises and the very principles of justice and equality it professes to champion.

Read More
The ANC’s déjà vu directive: The cadre playbook and the National State Enterprises Bill.
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

The ANC’s déjà vu directive: The cadre playbook and the National State Enterprises Bill.

In a significant move, the South African government unveils the draft National State Enterprises Bill, a legislative instrument harbouring the transformational blueprint for the country's state-owned enterprises (SOEs). The envisaged State Asset Management SOC Ltd., standing to replace the existing Department of Public Enterprises, signals a monumental shift in the administrative landscape, aiming to usher SOEs into an era of enhanced financial acumen and reduced political interference.

The initiative, steered by Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan, draws inspiration from successful governance models in Singapore and Malaysia. However, it is not without its critics, with apprehensions circling around provisions potentially enabling continued political patronage and a strategy perceived to bear Marxist undercurrents.

As the nation stands on the cusp of a defining era, the pathway is strewn with pressing questions and complexities, including significant economic hurdles illustrated by the dire state of entities such as Eskom. The critical dialogue enveloping this legislative move involves various stakeholders, each echoing a sentiment of cautious optimism, coupled with calls for robust accountability and transparency in the envisioned framework.

For deeper insights into this legislative initiative and its potential implications, delve into our detailed analysis in the full article available on Moneyweb.

Read More
South African agricultural sector showcases resilience in 2Q23
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

South African agricultural sector showcases resilience in 2Q23

In 2Q23, South Africa’s agricultural sector demonstrated remarkable resilience, registering a growth rate of 17.9%, a significant recovery from the near 5% decline in 1Q23. The Bureau for Food and Agricultural Policy (BFAP) has highlighted this sector as the fastest-growing in the nation, contributing a 4.2% increase to the GDP, markedly higher than the national quarterly growth of 0.6%. This remarkable growth trajectory is chiefly attributed to the field crops subsector, which accounted for 47% of the total agricultural Gross Value of Production (GVP) in this period. Maize and soybeans saw substantial increases in production, while sunflower GVP experienced a decline. The sugarcane industry also benefitted from global dynamics including delayed harvests in Brazil and reduced outputs in India. Although the sector faces potential challenges including fluctuating exchange rates and Brent Crude oil price dynamics, it leverages opportunities such as the depreciating rand which has fostered growth in the horticulture subsector. Moving forward, the sector should anticipate a mixed outlook with constrained revenue gains in the animal products and horticulture sectors, and potential modest contraction in the annual agricultural GDP. The industry remains cautiously optimistic, capitalising on strengths while navigating persistent challenges.

Read More
Decoding the decline in South Africa’s business liquidations
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Decoding the decline in South Africa’s business liquidations

In light of new data for July 2023 released by Statistics South Africa (Stats SA), the Southern African Advisory Company (SAAC) contemplates whether the decreasing trend in business liquidations in South Africa points to a healthy economy or if it warrants cautious interpretation.

A scrutiny of the recent figures indicates a favourable trajectory, noting a 15.2% decline in business liquidations compared to July 2022 and a year-to-date reduction of 14.2%. These percentages are derived from a thorough analysis which employed the X-12-ARIMA method to seasonally adjust the data, thereby providing a transparent overview of the prevailing economic conditions.

One noteworthy detail from the data is the prevalence of voluntary liquidations, a trend observed consistently across various sectors. This trend implies that businesses are opting for cessation as a considered strategy, embracing a mature approach to navigating economic difficulties rather than simply averting risk. While this shows a level of sagacity in business decisions, it also brings to the fore the prevailing instability in sectors such as "Financing, insurance, real estate, business services", which contrast with the continued resilience manifested in industries such as "Agriculture, hunting, forestry, and fishing" and "Mining and quarrying."

Despite the optimistic outlook presented by the downward trend in liquidations, the analysis offers a measured perspective, acknowledging the potential for a “zombie” economy where businesses are not thriving but merely surviving. This perspective entails a careful analysis of the existing business landscape to differentiate between genuine economic recovery and a misleading downturn in liquidation statistics.

The narrative of declining liquidations is also situated within a global context, aligning with economic revivals witnessed in countries like Brazil, India, Nigeria, and Indonesia, hence positing a worldwide economic recovery trend.

In conclusion, while the descending trend in business liquidations observed until July 2023 is generally encouraging, suggesting an onset of economic stability, it brings with it a complexity that necessitates vigilant monitoring. While there is cause for a cautious optimism, a sectorial analysis reveals enduring challenges in specific industries, indicating the criticality of sustained scrutiny to accurately gauge the health of the economy.

Read More
Turning time and assets
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Turning time and assets

In the realm of corporate renewal, professionals grapple with the challenge of navigating uncertainties to chart a path forward. This article delves into the principles underpinning successful turnarounds and strategies to forestall business mishaps. Highlighting indicators of corporate struggles, such as shifting client relationships and financial pressures, it underscores the non-negotiable nature of time. With time lost being irretrievable, businesses are urged to prioritise stringent financial reporting, clear goal-setting, revenue enhancement, and judicious asset management. By balancing internal incentives with transparent external dialogues, and emphasising the significance of revenue growth and cash flow, companies can harness the potential of dormant assets and optimise debt structures. The piece concludes by advocating for the wisdom of detached, seasoned professionals in guiding rejuvenation efforts.

Read More
Two cities, one tale: Tackling South Africa’s changing landscape
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Two cities, one tale: Tackling South Africa’s changing landscape

Johannesburg, once a gold rush beacon, now grapples with infrastructural decline and political instability, leading many to draw connections to the African National Congress's influence. Concurrently, Cape Town emerges as a favored destination for South Africa's affluent, especially from the white demographic, in a phenomenon termed “semigration.” Housing data from 2010 to 2022 reveals a 141% surge in Cape Town's house prices, doubling Johannesburg's 71%. Contributing factors include Cape Town's scenic allure, robust infrastructure, and consistent governance under the Democratic Alliance, attracting global giants like Amazon. This urban migration underscores a broader narrative: the growing identity and potential autonomy of the Western Cape, suggesting not only economic ascendancy but a potential clamor for self-determination.

Read More
Whispers of ‘tomorrow’s Post Office’
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Whispers of ‘tomorrow’s Post Office’

Steeped in history as old as South Africa itself, the Post Office SOC Ltd (SAPO) stands as a lasting emblem of our nation's commerce. In my latest piece, I delve into the fascinating narrative of one of our oldest institutions. This unvarnished analysis examines the precarious financial straits of SAPO and the business rescue blueprint that promises a lifeline. Is it a beacon of hope or simply a mirage in our economic landscape?

Read More
SA business liquidations show promising decline in 2023
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

SA business liquidations show promising decline in 2023

Delving into the heart of South Africa’s economy, recent data from Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) paints a comprehensive picture of both voluntary and compulsory liquidations across the nation up to the end of May 2023. While some sectors like 'Financing, insurance, real estate, business services' endure a high number of liquidations, others such as 'Electricity, gas and water', 'Mining and quarrying', and 'Transport, storage, communication' show significant resilience with low or zero liquidations. The broader view reveals a promising decline in total liquidations from May 2022 to May 2023, suggesting a possible resurgence in economic conditions or greater stability across industries.

As the narrative shifts towards optimism, the data suggests an economic environment moving towards stability, a trend that is both reassuring and promising for the future of South Africa's economy. The trend appears to be in line with a more expansive global economic recovery, providing further hope for businesses navigating their way through the economic landscape.

Read More
Covid-19 Loan Guarantee Scheme: bridging the gap or widening the divide?
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Covid-19 Loan Guarantee Scheme: bridging the gap or widening the divide?

The Covid-19 Loan Guarantee Scheme, launched by the South African government, was meant to be a lifeline for businesses struggling in the wake of the pandemic. However, a recent study by the Southern African Advisory Company (SAAC) questions the effectiveness of this initiative.

The scheme, intended to provide liquidity to businesses and facilitate economic recovery, was scrutinized in SAAC's comprehensive study, which merged data from the National Treasury and the South African Reserve Bank with case studies and business owners' personal accounts.

Despite the scheme's noble intentions, the study revealed several troubling aspects. The scheme's operational dynamics were found to be complex and unclear, making navigation particularly challenging for small and medium-sized enterprises. The study also discovered significant variability in the scheme's effectiveness. While it offered crucial support to some businesses, others were left behind due to lower-than-expected uptake or barriers to access.

Additionally, the scheme unintentionally favoured certain sectors and regions, exacerbating existing inequalities. For instance, businesses in rural areas or unconventional industries found it more challenging to qualify for support.

However, the study also highlighted the importance of continuous learning and adaptation, noting that the scheme had been revised in response to initial shortcomings. The researchers suggest that increased feedback and ongoing changes could make the scheme more effective in meeting businesses' evolving needs.

The study's findings have considerable implications for policymakers, financiers, and South Africans, particularly SMEs. While the scheme has provided relief to numerous businesses, safeguarding jobs and livelihoods, it has also highlighted critical gaps and unintended disparities in its reach. This reveals a need for greater awareness, accessibility, and potentially simplification of the process.

In conclusion, the findings act as a call to action. For businesses, they signal the need to actively seek out available support. For the government and banks, they highlight the necessity of continuous learning, adaptation, and commitment to inclusivity.

In the end, the author of the study warns of an anticipated increase in loan defaults due to ongoing economic implications of the pandemic and urges those struggling with loan repayment or seeking financial aid to seek assistance. The complete research paper will be published in the MedRN and SSRN's dedicated Coronavirus Journal in August 2023.

Read More
Unpacking employee rights in the fog of business rescue
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Unpacking employee rights in the fog of business rescue

The article titled "Unpacking Employee Rights in the Fog of Business Rescue" provides a deep-dive into South Africa's business rescue provisions, which serve as an important mechanism for protecting employees during periods of financial distress within a company.

It outlines the detailed process of initiating business rescue proceedings, and emphasises the significant role employees play during this procedure. The piece further discusses the protective measures employees are accorded, particularly their status as preferred unsecured creditors, offering them some financial safeguards.

The interplay between the Labour Relations Act and the business rescue provisions is also explored, highlighting how the former continues to protect employee rights even amidst business rescue proceedings.

The overall theme of the article is to underscore the balancing act between preserving business viability and safeguarding employee rights during the business rescue process.

Read More
Can ChatGPT predict the stock market?
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Can ChatGPT predict the stock market?

The research paper, "Can ChatGPT Forecast Stock Price Movements? Return Predictability and Large Language Models," by Dr. Alejandro Lopez-Lira and Dr. Yuehua Tang from the University of Florida, US, has become the most downloaded globally. The study examines the potential of large language models (LLMs) to analyze the credibility of news outlets and predict stock market returns, suggesting a future where artificial intelligence (AI) could significantly influence financial affairs.

The researchers have trained these AI models to scrutinize and rank the reliability of news sources using a vast collection of articles. GPT-4 exhibited impressive accuracy in evaluating sources, while GPT-3 showed an extensive recall of a range of articles.

The potential implications of such AI systems forecasting market returns based on news credibility analysis could dramatically transform how we understand and interact with financial news, potentially causing a paradigm shift in investment strategies and improving investor confidence.

However, the study also emphasizes the importance of acknowledging the limitations and ethical issues related to these models, such as irrelevant responses, inherent biases, data privacy concerns, and the reliability of AI predictions. The research thus marks a significant step towards merging technology and finance, prompting us to consider the possibility of algorithms serving as predictive oracles.

Read More
Who shall guard the guardians?
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Who shall guard the guardians?

Delving into Deloitte's Restructuring Survey 2023 reveals questionable methodology and a simplistic perspective on business rescue, raising doubts about its objectivity. Coupled with Deloitte's history of financial scandals, one must question the underlying motives of the report, suggesting it may serve more as a strategic marketing ploy than a truly insightful industry analysis.

Read More
A pratical guide to business rescue for small business owners
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

A pratical guide to business rescue for small business owners

Business rescue is a lifeline for companies in financial distress, charting a path away from potential insolvency towards renewed financial stability. This comprehensive guide dives into the heart of business rescue, revealing its critical significance and the role of a Business Rescue Practitioner as the captain steering the company through choppy financial waters. We cover everything from initiation processes, either voluntary or compulsory, to creditors' rights and the crucial steps involved in the business rescue journey. Business rescue could be your financial lifeboat; understand how it operates to effectively navigate your business towards calmer seas.

Read More
Blood is thicker than water, but can your family business survive?
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Blood is thicker than water, but can your family business survive?

Family businesses form the backbone of South Africa’s commercial landscape, but they face a unique set of challenges that can threaten their longevity. Succession planning, family disagreements, financial management, innovation, and professionalism are critical areas that need to be addressed for these businesses to thrive across generations. Implementing effective governance practices, encouraging open communication, adopting sound financial management, embracing innovation, and nurturing a culture of professionalism can help family businesses navigate these challenges successfully. With real-world examples such as African Rainbow Minerals and Reinet Investments, learn how you can secure the future of your family business.

Read More
Marxist theory meets South Africa’s economic struggles
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Marxist theory meets South Africa’s economic struggles

South Africa's economy, grappling with escalating unemployment and a plummeting GDP, reveals a disconcerting truth about the country's current predicament. The ruling African National Congress's (ANC) Marxist policies and the fallout from the Covid-19 pandemic have aggravated the situation, contributing to increased poverty and an exodus of foreign investments. The ANC's survival strategies appear to overshadow their focus on national economic issues, sparking rampant corruption, nepotism, and a lack of accountability. Such a scenario has caused would-be investors and entrepreneurs to retreat, further destabilising the economic landscape. As South Africa faces these mounting challenges, the call for significant reforms and increased governmental accountability is now more crucial than ever.

Read More
The legal framework for business rescue
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

The legal framework for business rescue

The Companies Act in South Africa provides a legal framework for business rescue, a process intended to rehabilitate financially distressed companies. To initiate business rescue, the company's directors file a notice of business rescue, including a statement of the company's financial position and a proposed business rescue plan, with the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission (CIPC). A business rescue practitioner then develops a restructuring plan, with the approval of creditors and shareholders, which becomes binding upon approval. South African courts have a clear approach to analysing business rescue proceedings, as highlighted by several case studies, taking into account factors such as the company's financial distress, assets, and cash flow.

Read More
The parables of survival: Lessons from the Nova Sharemax debacle
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

The parables of survival: Lessons from the Nova Sharemax debacle

The Nova Sharemax debacle serves as a stark reminder of the complexities and challenges that arise during business rescue and liquidation proceedings. When a company is declared insolvent, it triggers a desperate scramble among creditors for repayment. A central tenet that surfaces from this chaos is the preferential treatment given to secured creditors in business rescues and liquidations.

Read More
Business rescue: A technology for good
Christiaan Herbst Christiaan Herbst

Business rescue: A technology for good

Discover the potential of business rescue as a technology for ingenious thinking to avert insolvency. Explore how companies can restructure their affairs, restore themselves as going concerns, and seize opportunities amidst financial crises. Learn about the benefits of modern bankruptcy legislation and the principles guiding a robust insolvency regime.

Read More